Connect with Rohit Punyani: https://ownersasset.com/resource-libraryBook a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with a 1% target per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________In this episode, Hans is joined by Rohit Punyani, co-founder of The Owner's Asset and a former Wall Street CIO who oversaw $4 billion at a multi-family office and community bank. After 20+ years in financial services starting as a large-cap stock picker, moving into wealth management at Wilmington Trust, and ultimately running money for hundred-millionaires and billionaires—Rohit fell in love with whole life insurance. Now he's built a firm dedicated to helping small business owners buy whole life with pre-tax dollars through cash balance plans.

Chapters:

00:00 – Opening segment

01:50 – Rohit's background: from $2B mutual fund to multi-family office CIO

04:30 – How the wealthiest clients actually think (structure over IRR)

06:00 – Why affluent families pushed Rohit toward whole life

08:35 – The five pillars of wealth (and why investments rank third)

09:05 – Overcoming bias: how a Wall Street guy learned to love whole life

13:30 – Banking function: sourcing capital and the limits of margin loans

17:50 – Asset vs. liability: how to think about policy loan repayment

22:35 – Introducing cash balance plans: the 96% cousin of the 401(k)

25:25 – The four major differences between 401(k)s and cash balance plans

26:25 – Contribution limits: putting away up to $400K per year

28:45 – The three-to-five year commitment requirement

33:15 – Who's the ideal candidate (quarterly estimated tax payers)

38:00 – Why you can't use a PUA rider in a cash balance plan

42:25 – The "synthetic PUA": getting Uncle Sam to fund your policy

51:25 – The optionality argument: why this beats chasing rate of return

55:15 – Enhanced ERISA creditor protection inside the plan

58:55 – Building self-escrow systems for retirement

01:03:55 – Wholesale vs. retail pricing on whole life premium

01:06:25 – The distribution mechanics: pulling life insurance out of the plan

01:21:35 – Converting term insurance into a cash balance plan policy

01:24:35 – Asset allocation rules: the 40% life insurance cap

01:31:30 – The 5% corridor: why the IRS caps your returns

01:33:30 – The 50% excise tax on overfunded plans

01:39:55 – Whole life as the "high ground" in your portfolio

01:43:15 – Statement wealth vs. contractual wealth

01:53:55 – Pairing annuities with whole life inside the plan

02:00:00 – Rohit's personal retirement plan

02:06:35 – Designing your 401(k) as your pension (not "on steroids")

02:11:00 – Closing segment

Key Takeaways:

The wealthy don't worship at the altar of IRR. After running money for hundred-millionaires and billionaires, Rohit learned that affluent clients optimize for structure, behavior, and optionality before they optimize for return. T

The "synthetic PUA" reframes everything for IBC practitioners. You can't use a PUA rider inside a cash balance plan, which might make IBC enthusiasts dismiss it immediately. But think of the tax deduction itself as a synthetic PUA. .

Wholesale pricing changes the math entirely. To pay $100,000 of premium with after-tax dollars, you have to earn roughly $140,000 to $150,000 depending on your state.

The distribution arbitrage is the cherry on top. When you pull a $1 million policy out of the plan, you owe taxes just like an IRA distribution. But unlike an IRA, the custodian cannot withhold from the policy itself.

Book a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with a 1% target per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________In this episode, Hans returns for Part 2 of the IBC Masterclass, picking up where the first conversation left off. If Part 1 was about understanding what cash value actually is, this episode is about why your policy is structured the way it is, why you can't just dump everything into PUA, and what a real whole life illustration actually looks like line by line.

Chapters:

00:00 – Opening segment

03:35 – A brief history of the Modified Endowment Contract (MEC)

07:20 – Section 7702 and the tax benefits that make whole life work

10:35 – The arbitrary 7-year test and how Congress drew the line

17:45 – Why faster payment timeframes require larger premiums

20:30 – Visualizing the MEC line: where the IRS draws the boundary

24:15 – The consequences of MECing a policy (losing your tax benefits)

27:20 – Introducing the term rider: the third type of premium

29:40 – How a small term premium raises your MEC ceiling

31:50 – The 50/50 vs 20/80 tradeoff and when term riders are needed

35:50 – Reading the premium breakdown page

36:50 – Guaranteed vs non-guaranteed sides of the ledger

38:20 – The three assumptions baked into every illustration

45:50 – When your dividend exceeds your base premium

46:30 – Calculating year-over-year growth as a "savings rate"

50:20 – Why you never want premium payments to stop

53:20 – Closing segment

Key Takeaways:

Whole life insurance is so powerful that financial services firms had to lobby Congress to restrict it. In the 1980s, money flooded into whole life because CPAs were directing wealthy clients to use single-pay policies as a tax-favorable wealth transfer tool. Mutual fund companies, losing market share, lobbied for what became the 1988 TAMRA legislation and the Modified Endowment Contract rules.

The MEC line is the boundary your agent is structuring around. Section 7702A says that if you pay up your death benefit faster than seven years, your policy loses its life insurance tax treatment and becomes a Modified Endowment Contract. Once “MEC’d”, you cannot reverse it. Policy loans, cash value growth, and dividends all become taxable.

The term rider exists to expand your PUA allowance. By adding a small amount of term premium (often a few hundred dollars), you buy a large chunk of additional death benefit cheaply. That raises the MEC ceiling, which lets you pay more PUA premium without crossing the line.

The more you dial down base in favor of PUA, the more term you need. A 50/50 policy usually doesn't need a term rider. A 20/80 structure does. The tradeoff: more PUA means faster cash value, but it requires more careful structuring to stay under the MEC line.

A properly structured policy hits profitability fast. In the Jinx McCashValue example, the policy generates more cash value than premium paid by year three. By year 17, $20,000 of premium creates $41,000 of cash value growth in a single year. By age 65, the dividend alone exceeds the entire annual premium.
You should want to keep paying premium for as long as possible. Once your dividend exceeds your premium, every additional payment is a deeply discounted purchase of future tax-free growth. Hans frames this as capitalizing your system, not funding an expense. The day you have to stop paying is the day to be sad, not the day you've been waiting for.

Book a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with a 1% target per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________

In this episode, Hans walks through the mechanics of whole life insurance the same way he walks through it on a first call with every client. If you've ever been confused about premium structure, cash value, or why IBC practitioners pay what they pay, this episode is designed to make it finally click.

Chapters:

00:00 – Opening segment

02:10 – What cash value actually is (the $10,000 bond analogy)

06:40 – How time changes the present value of money

10:45 – Adding required payments and how they drag value down

14:20 – The job of an actuary and why term insurance is "cheap"

19:15 – Introducing the $20,000 at 20/80 premium structure

21:00 – Base premium explained (the 20% / $4,000 portion)

26:30 – Why base premium alone doesn't build cash value fast

30:15 – The Dave Ramsey critique and why it falls apart

35:40 – PUA premium explained (the 80% / $16,000 portion)

40:20 – How PUA generates immediate cash value (no future drag)

45:10 – Stacking dividends and the "wedding cake" effect

50:05 – Base vs PUA: which to lean on and when

53:20 – Reframing premium as savings, not an expense

56:15 – Closing segment

Key Takeaways:

Cash value is not a checking account. It's the net present value of a future death benefit, discounted by time and required premium obligations. Understand that and the rest of whole life insurance starts to make sense.

Time and required payments are the two forces that drag down cash value. Shorten the timeframe or remove required future payments, and the present value rises. This is the mechanical reason PUA premium converts to cash value almost immediately.

Term insurance is cheap because it's statistically unlikely to pay out. Only one to two percent of term policies ever pay a death benefit. You're buying a narrow, inexpensive slice of the actuarial curve, which is why it costs less than whole life.

Base premium is required and primarily buys protection. In a $20,000 at 20/80 structure, the $4,000 base premium puts a large death benefit in force but generates very little cash value in the early years.

PUA premium is optional and primarily buys cash value. That same structure directs $16,000 toward paid-up additions, which converts to cash value almost dollar-for-dollar immediately and also increases the death benefit.

Dividends compound the structure over time. Using dividends to purchase more PUA grows your pro-rata share of the company, which grows future dividends, which grows the policy further. This is why properly structured policies accelerate with age.

You have to understand the asset before you structure it. This is why the first call is about concepts, not your personal situation. The right premium structure can only be chosen after you understand what each dollar is actually doing.

Book a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with a 1% target per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________In this episode, Hans explains the macroeconomic reality most people feel right now. Your purchasing power is quietly declining, and it’s not by accident. From the rise of AI replacing real economic value to the mechanics of the national debt, this episode walks through how the system actually works.

He explains who we’re really in debt to, why the U.S. can’t stop borrowing, and how the constant refinancing of trillions in debt creates a self-reinforcing loop. As interest rates rise and more debt comes due, the Federal Reserve and Treasury are left with fewer and fewer options.

That leads to one likely outcome: yield curve control. A policy where the Fed steps in to cap interest rates and buy bonds with newly created money.

Chapters:

00:00 – Opening segment

02:27 – Why understanding the Fed actually matters

04:18 – Treasuries, global demand, and dollar fear narratives

06:52 – AI replacing jobs and collapsing value of labor

09:18 – Introduction to the national debt mechanics

14:02 – Why rising rates are a massive problem

16:48 – The $10 trillion rollover problem explained

20:18 – Why the U.S. must keep borrowing (no way out)

25:18 – Interest payments and the compounding loop

28:42 – The $12 trillion annual borrowing reality

31:22 – QE vs Yield Curve Control (key distinction)

36:05 – What this means for cash, savings, and bonds

37:12 – Impact on gold, Bitcoin, stocks, and real estate

39:08 – Practical strategy: protecting and positioning capital

45:20 – Closing segment

Most people don’t realize their standard of living is being propped up by a system that’s changing. If your job can be replaced by cheaper labor or AI, your income is no longer tied to real economic value, and that gap is starting to close.

The U.S. doesn’t “pay off” its debt. It refinances it. Roughly $10 trillion in debt comes due in a single year, and the government must borrow new money at current rates just to pay back old bondholders.

The Fed has limited options left. Cutting spending isn’t realistic, raising taxes won’t close the gap, and growing out of the debt isn’t happening fast enough. That leaves one primary tool.

Yield curve control is likely the next move. Instead of controlling how much it buys, the Fed sets a target interest rate and buys whatever amount of bonds it takes to keep rates there.

This policy quietly erodes purchasing power. Savings accounts, cash, and fixed-income assets lose ground over time as inflation stays higher than the returns they generate.

Hard assets and productive assets respond differently. Stocks, real estate, gold, and Bitcoin tend to rise in nominal terms while the value of the dollar declines.

You can’t control the system, but you can control your position within it. Understanding how money is created, how debt is managed, and where your capital sits determines whether you keep up or fall behind.

Book a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with a 1% target per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________Hans goes back to the fundamentals, pulling from one of the rarest books in the IBC world: The Economics of Life Insurance by Solomon Huebner. Written roughly 80 years ago, this book laid the intellectual foundation for how life insurance should actually be understood, not as a death benefit waiting to pay out, but as income protection against every form of economic death a family can face.

Chapters:

00:00 - Opening segment

06:00 - Introducing Solomon Huebner and The Economics of Life Insurance

08:30 - Reframing the concept: life insurance is income insurance

11:00 - Economic Death #1: Physical death and the 1 in 3 statistic

18:00 - The fire insurance comparison: why the math should embarrass us all

22:00 - Economic Death #2: The living death and why disability is the most costly outcome

29:00 - The waiver of premium rider and why disability insurance matters more

35:00 - Economic Death #3: Retirement death and not becoming a burden on your children

41:00 - The moral obligation: Huebner's case for insuring your human life value

44:00 - Closing segment

Key Takeaways:

Most people only plan for one of the three ways their income can die. Huebner lays out three distinct forms of economic death: physical death, total and permanent disability, and retirement. Only one of them puts you in the ground. All three wipe out your income.

The fire insurance comparison should be uncomfortable. Half of American homes carry fire insurance against an event that, if it occurs, destroys roughly 10% of the property on average. Death is a 100% certain event that produces a 100% loss of income.

The 1 in 3 statistic reframes everything. At age 30, roughly one in three workers will not reach the standard retirement age of 65. If you would not board a plane that had a 1 in 3 chance of not landing, you should not leave your family's financial future unprotected against those same odds.

Disability is the most expensive form of economic death, not physical death. When you die, your income stops and so do your resource needs. When you become totally and permanently disabled, your income stops and your resource needs increase, often dramatically, over a long period of time.

The waiver of premium rider is the one financial asset that keeps feeding itself when you can't. If you become disabled and lose your income, contributions to your brokerage stop, your savings account stops growing, your real estate stops getting funded.
Not insuring your human life value is a moral failure, not just a financial one. Huebner's language is direct and Hans does not soften it. If you understand the risk and choose not to protect against it, the loss does not fall on you. It falls on your wife and your children.

Book a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with a 1% target per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________

Hans brings back Travis McBride, a former helicopter pilot turned annuity and long-term care specialist, to walk through the entire annuity landscape. They start with the basics: what an annuity actually is, why only life insurance companies can offer them properly, and how the math of mortality pooling works in your favor when structured right. Then they get into the different flavors, from MYGAs to SPIAs to fixed index annuities with income riders, and make the case that right now, with rates still elevated, the payout environment is as strong as it's been in decades. The episode closes with a conversation about annuity audits and why anyone with an existing policy bought in a low-rate environment could be leaving thousands of dollars of guaranteed income on the table every single year.

Chapters: 00:00 - Opening segment02:15 - Introduction to Travis04:00 - Why annuities have a bad reputation and who benefits from that narrative 07:30 - What is an annuity? The fifth grade explanation 11:00 - Why only life insurance companies offer annuities 13:30 - The quarter million dollar example and how mortality pooling works 18:30 - The 4% safe withdrawal rule and why Hans doesn't trust it 22:00 - Sequence of return risk: why the order of returns breaks retirement plans 24:00 - Interest rates and why annuity payouts are at historic highs right now 27:30 - Quality capital vs. quantity capital: where annuities fit 33:00 - The VA disability claim is worth $2.5 million in annuity terms 38:00 - Types of annuities: MYGA, SPIA, DIA, and fixed index with income rider 45:00 - How annuity taxation actually works (and why it's complicated) 49:00 - The annuity audit: what it is and why your existing policy may be underperforming 55:00 - Real example: $21,000 guaranteed income upgraded to $28,500 at no cost 58:00 - The bond mentality shift: certainty vs. trading 1:01:30 - Who should consider an annuity and at what age 1:04:30 - How annuities fit into the protect, save, growth framework 1:07:00 - Closing segment

Key Takeaways:

Not every dollar's job is to maximize returns. Hans and Travis open with a framework that should reframe how you think about your whole strategy. Some capital is there for quantity, your retirement accounts chasing growth to overcome decades of illiquidity. Other capital is there for quality: certainty, guarantees, income you can build a life around.

The 4% safe withdrawal rule has a fatal flaw almost nobody talks about. The Trinity study that produced that number looked at 30-year market windows. If you reverse the order of those same returns, the same person runs out of money in year 13.

Sequence of return risk is the silent retirement killer. If the market drops in your first few years of retirement while you're withdrawing income, those early losses compound in reverse and permanently damage your long-term plan.

Annuity payout rates are tied to prevailing interest rates, and right now those rates are near recent highs. That means the guaranteed income you can lock in today is significantly better than what was available in 2020 when rates were scraping the bottom.

Book a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with 1% per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________

If you just buy index funds and chill, you're living on a financial fault line you don't even recognize. Most people have no idea that the shares in their 401k are being lent out to hedge funds, that their pension is invested in private credit funds currently locking investors out, and that the largest asset manager in the world is effectively in the red once you strip away goodwill and assets under management.

In this episode, Hans brings back the Phoenician League's Joe Withrow to break down why the quality of your capital matters more than the quantity, a concept inspired by economist Ryan Griggs. They start by unpacking the private credit bubble, how Blue Owl gated its fund, and why the contagion risk reaches into your 401k and pension whether you know it or not. Then they walk through a scorecard of asset characteristics and make the case that true diversification means owning assets across a range of purposes, not just stocks in different industries.

Chapters:

00:00 - Opening and Joe Withrow introduction

04:50 - Private credit is all over the news and here's why it matters

06:00 - Ryan Griggs and the concept: quality vs. quantity of capital

09:25 - What is private credit and how it grew from $250B to $3T

14:55 - Blue Owl gates its fund and contagion spreads

19:00 - Evergreen funds, fractional reserve dynamics, and the Ponzi comparison

23:25 - Your index fund shares are being lent to hedge funds

26:30 - Quality vs. quantity: building the asset scorecard

30:10 - Why insurance companies are the longest-surviving businesses in America

34:35 - Measuring the S&P 500 in gold: still down from 1999

39:30 - DOGE as the financial Epstein files

41:20 - Joe's equity portfolio: performance, composition, and why it's only 10-12% of his assets

49:45 - Gold, UPMA, and transporting value through time

52:25 - Bitcoin as collateral and birthing new assets from existing ones

1:00:35 - Real estate: cash flow over speculation

1:04:35 - Your home as an asset and the six-month self-sufficiency benchmark

1:10:55 - Investing is about ownership, not making more dollars

1:13:05 - BlackRock's balance sheet: the house of cards underneath $14T in AUM

1:15:25 - It's not as safe as you think to just buy VTSAX and chill

Key Takeaways:

Quality of capital matters more than quantity. Ryan Griggs coined the phrase, and it reframes the entire conversation. An asset that checks one box really well but leaves you exposed everywhere else is low-quality capital no matter how big the number beside it. Your financial strategy should score well across a range of attributes, not just returns.

Private credit is a $2-3 trillion shadow lending market that touches your retirement whether you know it or not. Hedge funds, pensions, 401k plans, and index funds are all connected to this market. Blue Owl gated its fund entirely, and the contagion is spreading to names like Morgan Stanley, JP Morgan, and BlackRock. When your money is trapped in a private credit fund, there is no FDIC and no guarantee you get it back.

Your index fund shares are not just sitting there. Vanguard and other fund managers lend your shares to hedge funds for short selling and collect fees for doing it. If those hedge funds face a liquidity crisis from private credit blowing up, and they cannot return the borrowed shares, the value of your underlying portfolio takes the hit.

Book a call: https://remnantfinance.com/calendar

Out Print the Fed with 1% per week: https://remnantfinance.com/options

Email us at info@remnantfinance.com or visit https://remnantfinance.com for more information

FOLLOW REMNANT FINANCE

Youtube: @RemnantFinance (https://www.youtube.com/@RemnantFinance)

Facebook: @remnantfinance (https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560694316588)

Twitter: @remnantfinance (https://x.com/remnantfinance)

TikTok: @RemnantFinance

Don't forget to hit LIKE and SUBSCRIBE

_____________________________

If everything fell apart and you had no income, could your family sustain itself for multiple years without a single payment coming in? Most people can't answer yes to that.

In this episode, Hans and Brian dig into why "rate of control" matters more than rate of return when it comes to your financial life. But first, they address the elephant in the room: Brian has been involuntarily activated for the Iran war, and the reality of what that means for his family, the business, and the country sets the stage for a broader conversation about what we actually control and what we don't.

Chapters:

00:00 - Opening segment

02:15 - Why this war has no plan and no endgame

07:30 - Iran's decentralized military and why decapitation didn't work

11:25 - "No matter who you vote for, you get John McCain"

13:05 - Democracy as a brand for globalism

20:05 - Poll numbers, Thomas Massie, and the veil being lifted

28:00 - Seeing it from the Iranian lens

30:10 - Transition: what we can actually control

31:30 - Credit to Nate Dean and the "rate of control" concept

33:05 - Why Hans doesn't check his dividend rate or loan interest rate

35:05 - Brian's policy loan paydown strategy across 11 policies

37:45 - Why the value of a whole life policy can't be fully quantified

38:45 - Peace of mind, access to capital, and the land purchase story

40:05 - The car loan example: isolating the value of control

43:50 - The all-in-one mortgage and velocity banking for control

47:00 - Behavior matters more than policy structure

48:00 - Stop being a passenger: be the CFO of your family

52:35 - Control your capital or someone else will

54:15 - You're already in the banking business

58:05 - Rate of control over rate of return

59:45 - Closing segment

Key Takeaways:

Rate of control is the financial metric that actually matters. Nate Dean of Unlimited Life Concepts and host of the Cash Flow Legendz podcast coined it perfectly: stop obsessing over rate of return and start asking what your rate of control is over your money.

A higher interest rate can be the better deal. Brian pays a higher rate on his all-in-one mortgage than he could have gotten with a VA or conventional loan. Hans has a policy loan at a higher rate than a dealership would offer. In both cases, the control those instruments give them is worth more than a percentage or two of arbitrage.

You can't put a dollar amount on the ability to pause your life. Brian's cash value position means his family can sustain itself for multiple years with zero income and zero payments. That kind of resilience doesn't show up in a rate of return calculation.

Dividend rates across insurance companies are smoke and mirrors. The gross dividend rate a company publishes gets reduced by mortality expenses, commissions, and net operating costs before you see a dime. A company advertising 6% could pay you less than one advertising 5% if the second company runs leaner. Don't compare dividend rates across companies as if they're apples to apples.
You are the CFO of your family whether you act like it or not. Someone is profiting from the banking function in your life. The mortgage company, the car lender, the credit card company, the tax man. Nobody cares about your family's financial future more than you do. Control your capital or someone else will.