What if gratitude isn’t a seasonal sentiment but a moral obligation that reshapes who we become? We take on a single line from the Eucharistic prayer—“It is right and just, our duty and our salvation, always and everywhere to give you thanks”—and follow it all the way from Sunday liturgy into everyday life. With a professor, a priest, a millennial engineer, and a rabbi at the table, we examine why failing to thank the Giver isn’t just impolite; it’s untrue, unjust, and spiritually dangerous.
We begin with the simple claim that gratitude is “right.” If every breath and moment is a gift, silence isn’t neutral—it’s wrong. From there we dig into “just,” drawing on the classical idea that justice gives each their due. If God is Creator, acknowledgment is due. We talk about the sting of ingratitude, the way entitlement blinds us like a goldfish that can’t see the water, and how the Eucharist itself is thanksgiving that trains our hearts to notice grace.
Then we tackle “duty,” pushing back on the modern impulse to ask, “What do I get out of it?” Commanded thanksgiving doesn’t drain love; it sustains it. Duty carries us to worship when feelings lag and, paradoxically, often returns the joy we thought we lacked.
Finally, we explore why thanksgiving is tied to “our salvation.” Ingratitude bends the soul inward and fractures the relationship with God and neighbor. Gratitude, practiced “always and everywhere,” isn’t about thanking God for evil; it’s about thanking God within every circumstance, naming mercies without romanticizing pain.
Along the way, we share morning prayers, stories about missed obligations, and practical ways to cultivate a habit of thanks that spills into justice, generosity, and hope.
If this conversation nudged you to notice even one overlooked gift today, share the episode with a friend, subscribe for more thoughtful dialogues, and leave a review telling us where you’re practicing “always and everywhere” gratitude this week.