In this eerie episode ofIt’s A Circle, the crew unravels the chilling legend of the Greenbrier Ghost—the only known case where a ghost’s testimony helped solve a murder.

In 1897, Elva Zona Heaster’s death was ruled natural… until her spirit allegedly returned to her mother with a shocking revelation. Was this truly a case of justice from beyond the grave, or just a desperate attempt to convict a guilty man?

Join Miller, Daryl, Damion, Tony, and Brandon as they explore the legend, the trial, and the lingering mystery of West Virginia’s most famous ghostly encounter.

👻 Truth, legend, or something in between? You decide.

In this chilling episode ofIt’s A Circle, the crew explores one of the internet's creepiest urban legends—the Elevator Game.

This eerie ritual claims to transport players to another dimension, but is it just a spooky story, or is there something more to it? With connections to real-life disappearances, including the mysterious case of Elisa Lam, the Elevator Game has left many wondering if there’s truth behind the legend.

Join Miller, Daryl, Damion, Tony, and Brandon as they break down the rules, dive into terrifying experiences, and debate whether this game is just harmless superstition—or a portal to the unknown.

🚪 Press the buttons at your own risk… and don’t talk to the woman on floor five.

In this eerie episode of It’s A Circle, the crew dives into the unsettling phenomenon of Shadow People—dark, shadowy figures that seem to lurk just out of sight.

Are they spirits, interdimensional beings, or just tricks of the mind? Reports of these mysterious entities span cultures and centuries, leaving behind more questions than answers.

Join Miller, Daryl, Damion, Tony, and Brandon as they explore creepy encounters, share theories, and debate whether Shadow People are paranormal visitors—or something even stranger.

🌑 Don’t turn off the lights for this one—you never know who’s watching.

In this episode of It’s A Circle, the crew unpacks the chilling case of William Bradford Bishop Jr.—a man who seemingly had it all until one horrific night shattered everything.

Bishop, a former State Department official, is accused of brutally murdering his family before vanishing without a trace in 1976. Decades later, questions still swirl. Was it premeditated? Where did he go? And is he still alive?

Join Miller, Tony, and Brandon as they explore the twists and turns of this baffling case, blending humor with haunting speculation about one of America’s most wanted fugitives.

🔎 Tune in for mystery, theories, and a search for answers that’s far from over.

In this gripping episode of It’s A Circle, the crew unpacks the shocking 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer—a case of jealousy, manipulation, and brutality that rocked Knoxville, Tennessee.

What led four teenagers down a dark path that ended in ritualistic violence? Was it a crime fueled by obsession, or something even darker?

Join Miller, Daryl, Damion, Tony, and Brandon as they explore the chilling details, discuss the aftermath, and add their signature humor to this tragic and unsettling case.

🔪 True crime, twists, and tough questions await in this haunting episode.

In this debut episode of It’s A Circle, the crew dives deep into one of the most bizarre pieces of Bigfoot evidence ever recorded—The Sierra Sounds.

Captured in the remote wilderness of California, these eerie vocalizations have baffled scientists and cryptid enthusiasts for decades. Are they proof of Sasquatch communication, elaborate hoaxes, or something even stranger?

Join Miller, Daryl, Damion, Tony, and Brandon as they analyze the recordings, debate their origins, and sprinkle in their signature humor along the way.

🔊 Plug in and listen to the wild whispers that started it all.