Television editor Tamar Federknopp watches The Karate Kid. Expecting a boring sports movie, she discovers a fun 80s teen movie with surprising character depth.

Video game and Television producer Rodney Altman watches Taxi Driver. A fan of director Martin Scorsese but skeptic of grimy 70s movies, he envisions various New York City cliches and considers the possibility of Travis Bickle finding Jesus.

Writer/Producer Alex Gradet watches The Notebook. Wary of Nicholas Sparks but a big fan of Ryan Gosling; he opens his heart to this film which could be a romantic classic or a twisty thriller about a gaslighting con-man in a retirement home.

Author, musician and podcaster Sebastian Bendix of Tentpole Trauma finally watches The Princess Bride. A huge 80s fantasy fan, he envisions a darker version where Wallace Shawn is an evil wizard, Andre the Giant lives in a cave and Carey Elwes is a swash-buckling hero with a magic sword.