New York Toy Fair is just around the corner and if you’re preparing to launch your toy or game at this event, learn this lesson: it WON’T sell itself! Buyers see hundreds of pitches, and even the best ideas can get lost in the noise.

The real secret? It’s not just what you pitch, but HOW you pitch it. So, how do you make buyers stop, pay attention, and want to play?

That’s exactly why I’m bringing back an episode with Barry McLaughlin & Jason Lautenschleger, who share how to pitch and stand out at New York Toy Fair.

In this episode of Making It In The Toy Industry, Barry & Jason share their wildest Toy Fair pitch stories, including the time Jason literally proposed with Game Night in a Can—and walked away with a deal! These longtime friends (who have competed on 11 game shows together) have mastered the art of pitching with energy, humor, and theatrics to grab buyers’ attention. From landing deals with Goliath Games and PlayMonster to turning trade show pitches into full-blown entertainment, their unique and fun approach proves that showmanship sells.

Barry & Jason reveal how mini-games during a pitch can instantly engage buyers, and how reading body language cues (like the "surprise inhale" and “writing the nods”) can help you close the deal faster. Plus, they explain why not knowing all the rules of the toy industry actually helped them innovate.

If you’re prepping for Toy Fair or looking to level up your pitch game, this episode is full of must-know strategies. Learn how to grab attention, keep buyers engaged, and turn a pitch into an unforgettable experience. Put on your headphones and get ready to SELL MORE TOYS!

Listen For These Important Moments

• [00:29] - Preparing for New York Toy Fair
• [02:17] - The Journey of Barry and Jason
• [06:03] - Creating Game Night In A Can
• [15:27] - First Toy Fair Experience
• [17:10] - Pitching Tips and Strategies
• [23:51] - Connecting Through Humor
• [24:15] - Adapting Your Pitch Strategy
• [26:25] - Memorable Pitching Anecdotes
• [30:50] - Handling Competition and Doubt
• [31:38] - Keys to Pitching with Pizzazz
• [33:07] - The Importance of Presentation
• [40:46] - Final Advice for Aspiring Game Creators

Send The Toy Coach Fan Mail!

Support the show

Popular Masterclass! How To Make & Sell Your Toy Ideas
Your Low-Stress, Start-To-Finish Playful Product Launch In 5 Steps
>> https://learn.thetoycoach.com/masterclass <<

Polarizing topic incoming... DEI.

When The Toy Coach was picking up steam, many people told me a focus on DEI and being black would be to the benefit of my business. There were so many opportunities to speak on and about diversity and struggle as a person of color that it was hard to feel justified looking the other way at those opportunities.

My instincts told me that the DEI initiatives and opportunities offered, while tempting, were not solid ground to build a business upon….and unfortunately, I was right.

This episode explores my personal feelings about the DEI initiative rollbacks that started with the US federal government and spilled out into a few corporations, how we feel, what we think, and what we’ll do now.

Be sure to check the show notes for links to black-owned businesses you may be interested in buying from.

Send The Toy Coach Fan Mail!

Support the show

Popular Masterclass! How To Make & Sell Your Toy Ideas
Your Low-Stress, Start-To-Finish Playful Product Launch In 5 Steps
>> https://learn.thetoycoach.com/masterclass <<

Let’s face it: toy brands get almost ALL the glory, but the inventors behind the product—people like you—deserve the spotlight too. In this episode of Making It in the Toy Industry, I’m sharing 5 lessons to take you from hidden genius to rising star, inspired by my own experience and my recent convo with Tim Walsh, inventor of ‘Blurt!’.

We’re talking about why advocating for yourself matters (yes, you can request your name on the box), how to time your ideas to ride the perfect trend wave, and why pitching just one idea is a rookie mistake. (Spoiler: you need a whole pipeline of concepts.)

I’ll also give some insight into how to spot the white space in the market, using data-focused tools and cross-industry trends.

Hit play if you agree with me and Tim Walsh that toy and game inventors are criminally unrecognized. 🙂


Listen For These Important Moments:

• [00:01:46] - Recognition for Toy Creators
• [00:07:27] - Collaborating with the Industry
• [00:10:55] - Designing for Connection
• [00:12:25] - Playtesting in Real-World Environments
• [00:14:10] - Timing and Persistence
• [00:18:23] - Pitching Multiple Ideas
• [00:20:50] - Finding White Space
• [00:23:28] - Drawing Inspiration from Other Industries

Send The Toy Coach Fan Mail!

Support the show

Popular Masterclass! How To Make & Sell Your Toy Ideas
Your Low-Stress, Start-To-Finish Playful Product Launch In 5 Steps
>> https://learn.thetoycoach.com/masterclass <<