This episode dives into the unsolved disappearance of Brianna Maitland, a 17-year-old girl who vanished in Vermont in 2004. We detail her life leading up to her disappearance, the circumstances surrounding her last known whereabouts, and the extensive investigation that followed. We examine various leads, including a potential connection to drug dealers, a possible sighting in Atlantic City, and a connection to serial killer Israel Keyes. While we discuss several possible explanations for Maitland's disappearance, including foul play and a staged accident, there is ultimately no definitive conclusion as to what happened to her.

This episodes dives into the disappearance of Maura Murray, an American woman who vanished in 2004 after a car crash in New Hampshire. We chronicle her life leading up to her disappearance, including her education and personal relationships, and then provide a thorough timeline of the events surrounding the car crash and subsequent search efforts. We also explore various theories surrounding Murray's disappearance, including possible suicide, abduction, or involvement in a criminal act. Despite extensive investigations and searches, Murray's whereabouts remain unknown, making her case one of the most enduring mysteries in recent American history.

This episode dives into the unsolved Alphabet murders, a series of three child murders that occurred in Rochester, New York, between 1971 and 1973. The victims were all young girls who were sexually assaulted and strangled, with their bodies being discarded in locations whose names began with the same letter as their first and last names. The murders, each of which generated intense public outrage, remain unsolved despite extensive investigation and the identification of several suspects. We detail the murders of Carmen Colón, Wanda Walkowicz, and Michelle Maenza, providing information about their lives, deaths, and the investigations that followed, highlighting the similarities between the cases and the suspects who have been investigated.

This episode describes the unsolved Hinterkaifeck murders, which occurred in 1922 at a Bavarian farmstead. The six victims, a family and their maid, were found murdered with a mattock, and the perpetrator(s) lived with the bodies for three days. We explore the strange occurrences preceding the murders, the investigation process, the inconsistencies found in the evidence, and the various suspects who have been investigated over the years. The murders remain a mystery to this day, despite the thorough investigation and numerous suspects.

This episode provides a comprehensive overview of the Madeleine McCann case, detailing the circumstances surrounding her disappearance in Portugal in 2007. We outline the timeline of events, including the initial investigation by Portuguese police, the McCanns' involvement in the case, the media frenzy, and subsequent inquiries by British police and German authorities. We explore different theories regarding her disappearance, including a possible abduction by a stranger, a burglary gone wrong, or the possibility that Madeleine wandered off. We also discuss the numerous leads that have been pursued, the role of private investigators, and the various suspects who have been investigated. We ultimately shed light on the complexities and controversies of the ongoing investigation.

This episode recounts the story of the West Memphis Three, three men convicted of murdering three young boys in 1994. The case was highly controversial, with many questioning the evidence against the accused and pointing to possible flaws in the investigation. The convictions were ultimately overturned in 2011 after new DNA evidence and juror misconduct were brought to light, leading to the release of the West Memphis Three after they entered Alford pleas, acknowledging the prosecution's evidence while maintaining their innocence. We then explore the investigation, trials, and appeals of the case, delving into evidence, witness testimonies, and the role of the media. We also examine the impact of the case on the families of both the victims and the accused, including the conflicting perspectives and the challenges of navigating a complex and emotionally charged situation.

This episode is a comprehensive account of the O.J. Simpson murder trial, a high-profile legal case that captivated the world in the mid-1990s. We detail the murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman, Simpson's arrest and subsequent trial, the defense strategy and the prosecution's case, the controversy surrounding the use of DNA evidence, and the media frenzy surrounding the trial. We also analyzes the political and social impact of the trial, including its influence on the national conversation about domestic violence and race relations in the United States. Finally, we examine the aftermath of the trial, including Simpson's subsequent civil trial and the ongoing debate about his guilt or innocence.

This episode provides a detailed account of the life and murder of Elizabeth Short, famously known as the Black Dahlia. We explore her early life, her move to California, and her aspirations to be an actress. We then chronicle the gruesome details of Short’s murder, including the discovery of her body, the autopsy findings, and the extensive police investigation. We also highlight the media frenzy surrounding the case, the numerous false confessions received by the police, and the various suspects who have been investigated over the years. We ultimately explore the enduring mystery of the case and the ongoing public fascination with its unresolved nature.