Subscriber-only episode

Send us a text

Was Wild Bill Hickok a larger-than-life hero or a product of wild exaggerations? This episode promises to uncover the truth behind Colonel George Ward Nichols' controversial portrayal of Hickok in Harper's New Monthly magazine. You'll hear about how Kansas newspapers didn't hold back in criticizing Nichols' hyperbolic claims and learn about the unfiltered character of journalism during that period. We also discuss Springfield, Missouri's transformation post-Civil War and how Union veterans influenced the town's atmosphere, bringing to light the simmering tensions and lasting resentments that defined the era.

Step back in time with us as we dissect the romanticized legend of Wild Bill Hickok, exploring his personal sense of honor and the complex relationships that shaped him. We delve into the infamous Hickok-Tutt gunfight—the pivotal event that catapulted Hickok into Western legend. And don’t miss our examination of the archetype of the Western lawman, highlighting how Hickok set the gold standard for future lawmen in Kansas cow towns. From a historic gunfight to the enduring mythos of Western law enforcement, this episode provides a comprehensive look at the man behind the legend and his lasting impact on American history.

Return of the Great Hunters
Cattle Drives Website
Legends of Dodge City Website
Order Books

Send us a text

What if the true story of resilience and struggle in American history has been overlooked for too long? Explore the harrowing journey of the Northern Cheyenne tribe after the Battle of the Little Bighorn. From the brutal winter attack on Dull Knife’s village by Colonel Ranald S. McKenzie to the relentless military pursuit leading to the eventual surrender at Fort Robinson, we unravel the heartbreaking events and the courageous leadership of chiefs like Dull Knife and Little Wolf. Join us as we uncover the tribe’s forced relocation to the Southern Cheyenne Reservation, a direct violation of the 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty, and the subsequent challenges they faced.

During the summer of 1877, the Northern Cheyenne's relocation journey led to unexpected cultural exchanges with the residents of Dodge City. These interactions challenged existing stereotypes and altered mutual perceptions. We'll discuss the stark environmental contrasts between the Northern and Southern Plains and what it meant for the Cheyenne's sense of identity and displacement. This episode delves into how these encounters questioned the very essence of a "way of life" and shaped the American historical narrative.

Lastly, we reflect on the legacy of the Cheyenne Exodus and why this significant migration remains lesser-known. This story's relevance to the Great Plains and its commemoration through monuments, museums, and cultural reenactments are discussed. We're honored to be joined by James N. Leiker, author of "The Northern Cheyenne Exodus in History and Memory," who shares his profound insights into this period. Tune in for an enriching conversation that bridges past and present, shedding light on the ongoing relevance of these historical events in contemporary identity struggles and rural depopulation.

Support the show

Return of the Great Hunters
Cattle Drives Website
Legends of Dodge City Website
Order Books

Send us a text

What if a single magazine article could immortalize a man into legend? This episode explores how Colonel George Ward Nichols' sensational account in Harper's New Monthly Magazine transformed James Butler Hickok into the iconic "Wild Bill." Through Nichols' eyes, we unveil post-Civil War Springfield, Missouri, and the momentous meeting in a dimly lit saloon that forever altered Hickok's legacy. Step back in time with us to experience the unique ambiance of a town recovering from war and the birth of a larger-than-life persona that captivated the nation.

Journey through the escalating tensions between Wild Bill and Davis Tutt, leading up to their legendary gunfight in Springfield's town square. We explore the clashing principles of Hickok's commitment to fairness and Tutt’s quick-tempered nature, detailing their dramatic showdown where honor and reputation were at stake. Relive the historic duel on July 22, 1865, with vivid recounts of the events that culminated in Tutt’s death and Wild Bill's rise to legendary status. Feel the intensity and fateful actions that carved an indelible mark on American folklore, solidifying Hickok's place in history.

Support the show

Return of the Great Hunters
Cattle Drives Website
Legends of Dodge City Website
Order Books